Many anglers together with conservationists were disappointed concluding calendar month when the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission’s Atlantic Menhaden Management Board caved inwards to the demands (and peradventure threats) from the Omega Protein Corporation together with the Commonwealth of Virginia, together with failed to adopt interim reference points that would receive got required managers to consider menhaden’s value every bit a provender fish, every bit good every bit the mere sustainability of the fishery, when adopting annual quotas.
For over the past times decade or so, it has acquire out increasingly clear that traditional single-species management, which considers the harvest of each species inwards a vacuum, together with non inwards the context of entire ecosystems, is non the best agency to care fisheries, peculiarly fisheries for provender fish—the fish that everything else, including the most valued commercial together with recreational species, feed on.
Although at that topographic point may hold out exceptions, provender fish to a greater extent than oftentimes than non receive got really depression value, together with to hold out profitable, must hold out prosecuted on a high-volume basis. Thus, nosotros consider the menhaden fishery province nearly 1.75 billion pounds of product, that’s worth a mere $181 meg dollars—just 10 cents per pound. That’s a lot of fish beingness sold for really piddling money, which volition halt upward every bit nutrient for farmed fish inwards China, instead of for striped bass, manlike somebody monarch mackerel together with humpback whales inwards the waters of the U.S.
While menhaden are an of import provender fish along the entire East Coast, but it’s slow to fence that upward inwards New England, it’s importance is eclipsed past times that of Atlantic herring.
Herring back upward a fishery, too. It’s non every bit large every bit the 1 for menhaden—a piddling less than 138 meg pounds are landed—and the fish are a piddling to a greater extent than valuable—about 21 cents per pound—but withal falls good inside the “high volume, depression value” category.
But herring aren’t low-value inwards the New England ecosystem. They are critical provender for bluefin tuna, every bit good every bit for to a greater extent than mundane, but withal valuable species such every bit striped bass together with cod. And when the herring aren’t around, the bigger fish that swallow them, together with are inwards plough sought past times fishermen, oftentimes aren’t around either.
John Pappalardo, executive manager of the Cape Cod Commercial Fishermen’s Alliance, says that
“Our guys are non angling the agency they did 12 years agone around the Cape because those fish aren’t at that topographic point because the bait isn’t there. We alive inwards a migratory corridor here. We depend on the bait to hold out there.”
The region’s fishermen, both commercial together with recreational, receive got asked the New England Fishery Management Council to draft a regulation that would forcefulness the large herring trawlers to fish further offshore, together with forestall them from impoverishing the inshore ecosystem.
It’s a controversial request, non alone because of the inevitable opposition from the large trawl operators, but because it involves the much-debated topic of “localized depletion,”
“a reduction of population size, independent of the overall condition of the stock, over a relatively modest spatial expanse every bit a effect of intensive fishing.”
Thus, intensive provender fish harvest tin laissez passer on the sack effect inwards localized depletion of a species occurring inwards 1 item place, at 1 item time, fifty-fifty though the overall stock of fish is extremely healthy. That has led to the concept beingness challenged when brought upward inwards a management context. As one onetime fellow member of the Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council, who has had to bargain alongside the inquiry at diverse meetings, has written
“So, some manufacture reps receive got successfully argued that it’s non ‘depletion’ or a conservation number at all. It’s just a ‘gear conflict’ issue—big industrial boats impacting smaller boats. By framing it inwards this way, they tin laissez passer on the sack fence that they receive got a correct to hold out at that topographic point every bit much every bit whatever other resources user. I’ve heard manufacture reps tell that no 1 grouping ‘owns the ocean.’ That may hold out true. But if that’s the case, 1 resources user shouldn’t hold out able to ruin things for the residue of us…this IS a populace resource.”
The practiced tidings is that on Dec 5, the Council responded to the Cape Codder's concerns past times releasing a draft Amendment eight to its fishery management invention for Atlantic herring for populace comment. Of the Amendment’s 10 options, ix (the 10th is condition quo management) would each
“establish a long-term acceptable biological grab (ABC) command dominion that ‘may explicitly trouble organisation human relationship for the herring’s move inwards the ecosystem together with address the biological together with ecological requirements of the stock.”
That’s a large deal.
Regulations—which is what would effect from a command rule—that would “explicitly account” for a provender fish’s “role inwards the ecosystem” were precisely what folks hoped would come upward out of concluding month’s menhaden meeting. While there’s withal a run a peril that volition occur inwards the future—menhaden-specific ecosystem reference points are withal beingness developed; the rejected interim reference points were far to a greater extent than generic—seeing the same number crop upward inwards the instance of Atlantic herring makes it clear that managers withal consider value inwards the concept, applied to other provender species.
Of course, that doesn’t hateful that such a command dominion volition hold out adopted; the large trawl operators volition hold out pushing difficult for condition quo. They’re the folks best positioned to select coin together with lobbyists together with political connections to comport on this issue—and if we’ve learned anything from the Gulf recreational crimson snapper reopening together with the New Bailiwick of Jersey summertime flounder debacle, it’s that money, lobbyists together with political connections, rather than practiced science, is what matters alongside the folks currently belongings the reins inwards Washington.
But the really fact that the New England Fishery Management Council, a council that has historically lagged all of the others when it comes to conserving fish stocks, is looking at Atlantic herring inwards an ecosystem context gives some ground for promise inwards a twelvemonth that has seen a number of U.S. fish stocks select serious torso blows from a newly erratic management system.
This is an number worth following, worth commenting on, together with worth supporting, together with may stand upward for a piddling practiced tidings at an otherwise dismal time.
New England Council Considers Herring's Component Inwards Ecosystem
4/
5
Oleh
Admin
